logo Sphere
Logo Université Paris-Diderot Logo Université Paris1-Panthéon-Sorbonne


Sur ce site

Sur le Web du CNRS

Accueil du site > Publications > Ouvrages parus > Scientific Sources and Teaching Contexts Throughout History : Problems and Perspectives

Scientific Sources and Teaching Contexts Throughout History : Problems and Perspectives

Alain Bernard et Christine Proust (Eds.)

Ce livre collectif est le résultat de plusieurs années
de séminaires organisés conjointement
par l’axe "histoire des sciences en Asie" de REHSEIS
(aujourd’hui SPHERE)
et le Centre Alexandre Koyré
entre 2005 et 2008.

4e de couverture : This book examines the textual, social, cultural, practical and institutional environments to which the expression “teaching and learning contexts” refers. It reflects on the extent to which studying such environments helps us to better understand ancient or modern sources, and how notions of “teaching” and “learning” are to be understood.
Tackling two problems : the first, is that of certain sources of scientific knowledge being studied without taking into account the various “contexts” of transmission that gave this knowledge a long-lasting meaning.
The second is that other sources are related to teaching and learning activities, but without being too precise and demonstrative about the existence and nature of this “teaching context”. In other words, this book makes clear what is meant by “context” and highlights the complexity of the practice hidden by the words “teaching” and “learning”. Divided into three parts, the book makes accessible teaching and learning situations, presents comparatist approaches, and emphasizes the notion of teaching as projects embedded in coherent treatises or productions.

 :: Springer, Series : Boston Studies in the Philosophy and History of Science, Vol. 301
 :: 2014
 :: IX, 334 p. 227 illus.
 :: eBook : ISBN 978-94-007-5122-4

Contributors : Alain Bernard, Andrea Bréard, Florence Bretelle-Establet,
Eva Caianiello, Anne-Marie Chartier, Karine Chemla, Giovanna C. Cifoletti,
Philippe Clancier, Stéphane Lamassé, Christine Proust, Alexei Volkov.


  • Alain Bernard and Christine Proust, General Introduction.

  • PART I : Holistic Approach.
    • Anne-Marie Chartier, The teaching context and reading from the 16th to the 19th centuries : The role of the memorization of texts in learning.
    • Philippe Clancier, Teaching and learning medicine and exorcism at Uruk during the Hellenistic period.

  • PART II : Critical Approach.
    • Christine Proust, Does a master always write for his students ? Some evidence from Old Babylonian scribal schools.
    • Alain Bernard, In what sense did Theon’s commentary on the Almagest have a didactic purpose ?.

  • PART III : Comparative Approach.
    • Stéphane Lamassé, Relationships between French “practical arithmetics” and teaching ?.
    • Andrea Bréard, On the transmission of mathematical knowledge in versified form in China.
    • Giovanna C. Cifoletti, Mathematical Progress or Mathematical Teaching ? Bilingualism and Printing In European Renaissance Mathematics.

  • PART IV : Zooming Approach.
    • Eva Caianiello, Leonardo of Pisa and the Liber Abaci. Biographical elements and the project of the work.
    • Alexei Volkov, Didactical Dimensions of Mathematical Problems : Weighted Distribution in a Vietnamese Mathematical Treatise.
    • Florence Bretelle-Establet, Learning and Teaching Medicine in Late Imperial China.

    • Karine Chemla, On the sources of the historian of science from the perspective of a history of education.

  • INDEX.